Y Tu Mamá Muy Bien

reviewed Fri, 03 May 2002

Quite a change from director Alfonso Cuarón's previous films, Victorian literary adaptations (Great Expectations and A Little Princess), Y Tu Mamá También is raunchy and gritty.  As Scott put it, some parts are uncomfortable to watch in a theater with other people.  You may not want to take your parents to this one (take it from me -- I saw a similarly sex-saturated movie, Henry and June, with my father.  Not a recommended activity).  But it's energetic and fun, even if it comes off a bit like, as one critic said, a more profound -- and graphic -- version of American Pie

I enjoyed most the dry narration that tracks morbid tangents to their conclusion (an accident that causes a traffic jam, the omnipresent memorial crosses by the side of the highway, the fate of a passing herd of pigs) -- that kind of deadpan sense of humor infuses the movie -- and the atmosphere of this road movie that travels through several levels of Mexican society, from the palatial home of a high-ranking politician to roadside huts.  I was less enthralled with the notion that a woman shows herself to be liberated by fucking a couple of teenage boys, and the ending that helps to explain why the woman, Luisa (Maribel Verdú) behaved as she did felt unsatisfying and something of a cop-out.

Verdú and the actors portraying the two sex-obsessed teenagers who cajole her into joining them for a road trip, Gael García Bernal and Diego Luna, are charismatic and endearing.  The film feels realistic, intimate, immediate.  I don't think it deserves the breathless superlatives many critics are heaping upon it, but it's a charming, unassuming, fun movie.

A note to those of you in the DC area:  we saw this at the new Landmark Theater at Bethesda Row, which is a state-of-the-art venue for art cinema (i.e., all stadium seating, no gigantic columns smack-dab in the middle of the room à la Janus).  They have a few kinks to work out, but nothing approaching the fuck-up level of Regal Cinemas -- they showed the movie on time with no problems.  Please, please patronize this theater so that Landmark will open another one in a more central location (they're looking at sites downtown if the Bethesda location does well).

Back to homepage
Reviews A to F
Reviews G to L
Reviews M to R
Reviews S to Z
Search