Oscar's Shorts, 2002

reviewed Tue, 18 Mar 2003

Once again, Apollo Cinema brings us the animated and live-action short films
nominated for the Academy Awards.

I’ll start with the animated shorts, because this first one was my favorite.  Mt. Head
(Atama Yama) is a bizarre Japanese fable of a stingy man … and that’s all I’m going
to tell you.  As it began, I thought the animation was unique and very cool, particularly
compared to the soulless computer-animated entries that followed.  But the film as
a whole won me over – it’s narrated in a sing-song, Kabuki-style chant, and it’s
brilliantly inventive and hilarious.  Best line in a movie so far this year:  “The man
threw himself into his head pond…”  You’ll just have to go see it to figure it out.
Unfortunately, it’s not online, but you can check for a screening near you.

I don’t know how anyone could vote for another contender after Mt. Head’s riotous
uniqueness, but I’d be willing to be that the Academy goes for one of the two slick,
computer-animated entries.  Mike’s New Car is a lazy, uninspired trifle using the
Monsters, Inc. characters voiced by John Goodman and Billy Crystal.  The
Chubbchubbs! likewise coasts on previously established fame:  it’s a cutesy cartoon
populated with sci-fi creations like Jar-Jar  Binks, Yoda, Robby the Robot, and the
alien from Alien(s)3IV and scored to R&B classics.  The other way the voters might
go is Das Rad (Rocks), a stop-motion animation of two rocks watching the world
go by – it looks cool, but it doesn’t really have a point.  The dregs of the barrel is
The Cathedral, which looks like a video game, except a really slow and pretentious
one, or one of those air-brushed fantasy posters with planets and stars and armor-
clad Amazons with swords.  Just dreadful.  It was the only short that got absolutely
no reaction from the audience.

The first short in the live-action set turned out to be the best.  This Charming Man
(Der Er En Yndig Mand) condemns racism, but in a way that sometimes makes
you wonder if it isn’t indulging in some itself.  Lars Hansen, a native Dane, finds
his identity confused with Pakistani immigrant El Hassan and, for reasons too
complicated to go into, he disguises himself as the Pakistani.  I’m not sure blackface
is going to win you an Oscar, but you never know.  It is quite funny, though, and
really very sweet.  It’s also the only one that really tells a full story.

The next two films had the same gimmick of a last-second twist ending that
invalidated everything that came before, but in one, it was funny, and in the other,
it just felt mean-spirited.  Fait d’Hiver (Gridlock) finds a husband, stuck in traffic,
using his new cell phone to call home, with startling results.  Although you could
argue that this film was a tad callous, it came off as more of a joke (albeit a joke
that more than half the audience didn’t get.  The people in front of me actually
turned around to ask me what the ending meant – ten minutes later).  By contrast,
J’attendrai le suivant (I’ll Wait for the Next One) yanks the rug out from under
you with a rather vicious jerk.  It starts out with a horrible vision of my future – a
young man announces to a Metro car that he can’t find a date and he’s tired of being
single, so would any interested young women please make themselves known – and
ends with an even more horrifying vision of my even more likely future.  Inja (Dog)
is a message movie, using a young black boy, a white landowner, and a dog as a
metaphor for apartheid.  It’s nicely done, but its patently poetic-justice ending is too
morality-play for my taste.

And on the way to the Metro after the show, I got to see a wrecking ball smashing into
a building, which is just undeniably cool, even if it was kind of a small wrecking ball.
That was the second fortuitously cool thing to happen to me today; earlier, I was
waiting in line at the pharmacy, and the guy in front of me offered me over $6 in
Metro fare cards – he said he was moving to Mexico that day and didn’t have anyone
else to give them to.  Of course, less cool is the medication I was getting, which I was
distressed to see is prescribed not only for my stomach condition, but also for (among
an amazingly varied and long list of problems) bed-wetting.  So now I’m mortified to
think that, the next time I’m unconscious in a hospital, a doctor will look at my list of
meds and yell to the nurse, “Get a rubber sheet!  Hurry!”

Back to homepage
Reviews A to F
Reviews G to L
Reviews M to R
Reviews S to Z
Search